Composite vs Wood Deck: Which is Better for You?

When I first started planning my deck renovation, I felt overwhelmed by all the material options available. Wood and composite decking dominated every conversation with contractors and neighbors.

You’re probably facing the same choice right now, wondering which material will give you the best value for your money and time.

I’ve spent months researching both options, talking to homeowners who’ve lived with their decks for years, and examining real world performance data. This article breaks down everything you need to know about wood versus composite decking.

I’ll walk you through the costs, maintenance requirements, durability, and appearance differences so you can make a confident decision.

You can trust this comparison because it’s based on actual homeowner experiences and unbiased research, not sales pitches. Let’s find the perfect decking material for your home.

What Is Composite Decking?

Composite decking combines wood fibers with plastic materials to create boards that mimic wood’s appearance.

I’ll be honest with you. When I first heard about composite decking, I thought it was just fancy plastic. I was wrong.

Composite boards mix recycled wood fibers with plastic resins. This combination creates something that looks like wood but acts differently. Most brands use either polyethylene or PVC as the plastic component.

The wood fibers give it texture. The plastic makes it weather resistant.

Here’s what surprised me most: composite decking comes in dozens of colors and grain patterns. Some boards look so much like real wood that guests can’t tell the difference.

The manufacturing process involves heating and molding these materials together. This creates boards that won’t rot, splinter, or need annual staining.

What Is Wood Decking?

Wood decking uses natural lumber, typically pressure treated pine, cedar, or exotic hardwoods.

Wood decking is exactly what you think it is. Real wood planks.

I’ve worked with three main types. Pressure treated lumber is the most common choice. It’s affordable and widely available at home improvement stores.

Cedar costs more but smells amazing and naturally resists insects. Redwood offers similar benefits but comes with a higher price tag.

Then there are exotic hardwoods like ipe and mahogany. These dense woods last decades but cost significantly more upfront.

Wood decking requires regular maintenance. You’ll need to clean, sand, and stain every few years. But many homeowners love the authentic look and feel that only real wood provides.

The biggest advantage? Wood is completely natural and biodegradable when its useful life ends.

Composite Decking Vs Wood Decking: The Pros & Cons

Let me break this down for you in the simplest way possible. I’ve created a table that shows exactly what you’re getting with each option.

The choice really comes down to this: pay more upfront for less work later, or pay less now but invest time in maintenance.

I personally think both options have their place. It depends on your budget, available time, and personal preferences.

Should You Opt For A Composite Or Wood Deck?

Your decision depends on four key factors: your budget, local weather, how you use your outdoor space, and what looks best to you.

I wish I could give you a simple yes or no answer. But choosing between composite and wood isn’t that straightforward.

Your budget matters most. Can you afford the higher upfront cost of composite? Or do you prefer spreading costs over time with wood maintenance?

Think about your climate too. I live in a humid area where wood decks struggle. If you’re in a dry climate, wood performs much better.

Here’s something most people don’t consider: your lifestyle.

Do you host parties every weekend? Composite handles heavy foot traffic better. Are you handy with tools and enjoy weekend projects? Wood might suit you perfectly.

Aesthetics play a huge role. Some homeowners only want authentic wood grain. Others prefer the consistent look of composite boards.

Now let’s talk timeline. Planning to sell within five years? Wood’s lower initial cost makes more sense. You won’t recoup composite’s premium in such a short time.

But if this is your forever home, composite’s long term savings become attractive. I calculated that composite pays for itself after about 12 years when you factor in maintenance costs.

The bottom line? There’s no wrong choice here. Both materials can create beautiful outdoor spaces when chosen thoughtfully.

Comparison Between Composite and Wood Decking

Here’s a complete comparison table I put together after researching both options thoroughly:

The bottom line: Wood is cheaper initially, but composite costs less over its lifetime. I calculated that after 15 years, composite actually becomes the more economical choice.

Decking Installation: Considerations And Tips

Here are practical tips to help you plan and execute a successful deck installation project.

Installation Tips:

• Hire a structural engineer for decks over 8 feet high or if you’re unsure about support requirements
• Check local building codes and obtain permits before starting any construction work
• Plan for proper drainage by installing the deck with a slight slope away from your house
• Use stainless steel or galvanized fasteners to prevent rust stains and structural weakness over time
• Leave gaps between composite boards for thermal expansion, but butt wood boards tightly together
• Install blocking between joists every 4-6 feet for added stability and reduced bounce
• Consider accessibility needs like ramp access or wider doorways if you plan to age in place
• Schedule inspections at key stages rather than waiting until the project is completely finished
• Budget an extra 15-20% beyond your initial estimate for unexpected issues or material waste

Conclusion

I’ve walked you through the major differences between composite and wood decking. Composite costs more upfront but saves time and money on maintenance over the years. Wood offers authentic beauty at a lower initial price but requires regular care to stay looking good.

Your choice comes down to personal priorities. Choose composite if you value low maintenance and long-term durability. Pick wood if you prefer natural materials and don’t mind seasonal upkeep tasks.

Both materials can create beautiful outdoor spaces when properly installed. Consider your budget, climate, and how long you plan to stay in your home. There’s no universal right answer here. The best decking material is the one that fits your specific situation and lifestyle needs perfectly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Decking Material Offers Better Value For Money?

Composite decking provides better long term value despite higher upfront costs. When you factor in 25+ years of minimal maintenance versus wood’s regular upkeep expenses, composite typically saves money over time.

How Long Does Each Type Of Decking Actually Last?

Wood decking lasts 10-15 years with proper maintenance and care. Composite decking can last 25-30+ years with just basic cleaning, making it a more durable long term investment.

Can I Install Either Type Of Decking Myself?

Both materials are suitable for DIY installation if you have basic carpentry skills. Wood is lighter and easier to cut, while composite requires special tools but offers more forgiving installation tolerances.

How Do Weather Conditions Affect Each Material?

Composite handles extreme weather better and won’t rot or warp like wood can. However, composite gets much hotter in direct sunlight, while wood stays cooler and feels more comfortable barefoot.

What Maintenance Will I Need To Do Each Year?

Composite decking only needs annual cleaning with soap and water. Wood decking requires cleaning, sanding, and staining every 2-3 years plus regular inspections for damage or loose boards.